Just be ‘real.’
It is such a simple concept, and yet one of the hardest realities to actually live… being ‘real.’ I find that people who have been in church for years, cannot accept reality, and the younger people who are desperately searching for something ‘real’, can be so open to it.
My goal is to be real, while not losing sight of who God is.
Religion takes away who we are. Covers it up and creates a persona of perfection that is false.
However, I find there is a tendency when moving out of legalism to not only be real, but to throw the baby out with the bath water. I understand that when we have been indoctrinated so far to one side of an issue (ie. our behavior must be appropriate to be accepted in ‘church’) and we finally realize this is killing us, the knee-jerk response is to move as far from that position as we can. So we move to what we perceive is complete freedom. (Yes, I know this from my own life, as well as observing others). The pendulum has now gone from one extreme to the other.
Now we no longer have to ‘behave,’ so we use our freedom to discover all the ways we can mis-behave. We attempt to see how close we can get to the cliff without falling off. I think in some ways this process can be helpful in loosing the grip of legalism, but it can be self-destructive when taken to extremes. When we moved from an abusive and legalistic church, we found ourselves in a small congregation that believed you could “live like hell, and still get to heaven.” We began experimenting with our freedom. And I must admit, it felt really great. However, over time we discovered that Paul’s words in 1 Corinthians 6:12 to be true.
“Everything is permissible for me”—but not everything is beneficial. “Everything is permissible for me”—but I will not be mastered by anything.
What can happen is that we create a new rule that says I can do anything. Sure, but not everything is helpful, nor good, nor beneficial to us, and sometimes our freedom can harm others. Some things can harm us physically, emotionally and spiritually, so we eventually find our way back to a middle ground that rejects legalism and religion, and encompasses love and grace, while using some good old fashioned common sense. I hope some of this makes sense to anyone besides me, lol! I’m still stomping around in this issue, trying to figure out exactly where I stand on all of this. It will take me the rest of my life to finish this journey, and I’m finally becoming OK with that.
But in this process we must reject the temptation to judge someone else’s walk. It is simply not up to us to decide whether they are “good-enough” or “behaving enough” to be acceptable. I have friends who land on either side of this issue. Some who are bound up in religion…. and others who walk the wild side well beyond my comfort zone. And yet they love Jesus. Can that be enough for us?
This post started out with the question of whether we can ‘be real AND be saved.” Absolutely. I believe we can be real if we drop the perfection seeking, behavior management program that we ‘think’ we are supposed to be following, and follow Jesus instead. More than this… I think we MUST learn to be real and authentic people, if we want others to be able to see Jesus in us. I suspect that the religious cloak prevents anyone from really knowing us, and from seeing the things at work inside of us, and it is also an turn-off for many who are looking for something ‘real.’ Perhaps this statement is too strong… but it is where I stand at the moment.
I guess my entire point is this… we need to be real, authentic people who are so in love with Jesus that we spill that out over all the people around us.
Love God, Love People. To me, that is the crux of the matter.
This was long… my apologies… but if you have thoughts, I’d love to hear them.

Great post. Being real is something I struggle with, too. I don’t fit in at church because I know if I spoke one tenth what was in my head I’d be shunned. And I still have the pull of old behaviors that makes me not want to be open with others, as well as always making me feel unworthy. Sometimes I think that comes from taking myself WAY too seriously.
Comment by Jim — January 1, 2009 @ 12:14 pm
You know, Jim, I think that you are probably right. If you get “too” real within many churches, you probably would be shunned. And I think that is so very sad.
I take myself way too seriously as well. And I’m working on that one. But in the meantime, I’m trying to learn to at the very least be real with God.
My thoughts on this are leading towards a possible new post as well… thinking about how we can allow other people to be real around us.
Comment by HW — January 1, 2009 @ 12:19 pm
This is a fabulous post! I absolutely understand. When I left church I spent a season trying to determine where God’s boundaries were for me (rather than the boundaries that had been put upon me in church), and in the process I did swing to the opposite extreme for a time. I had to explore, and yes, it was destructive in some ways, but it was far more healing than it was destructive. The best part is what you said about learning not to judge other people’s journeys.
The key, I suppose is being willing to recognize the boundaries when we see them…because when there is no one telling us (or we’re not letting anyone tell us) where they are, they can be easy to miss. That was my prayer the entire time “Lord, protect me from myself, because left to my own devices I don’t know where this will end”…and he did.
This was great, thanks for writing it.
Comment by Erin — January 1, 2009 @ 2:49 pm
Your thoughts are my thoughts, Heidi.
I’ve been working on a post that says much the same. It’s been my question now for so long…how free are we? I’ll be posting it in the next day or so.
I’m just relieved someone else is thinking about this. I don’t feel so alone. You know, part of what I’ve felt, moving away from legalism and understanding the binding force of shame, well…I’ve flet almost a rudderless existence. Not really sure which way to steer.
You’ve said it well. Thanks, Heidi!
Comment by Michelle — January 1, 2009 @ 3:14 pm
Erin, I subscribe to your blog! You are very welcome. I’m glad that you could relate. I also have asked God to keep me from myself, and to keep me from falling into deception.
Having you comment reminds me…
A few months ago a pastor relative of mine was telling me about a church in Portland that some people they knew had started, actually allowed swearing from the pulpit. She was horrified (I wondered if it is yours?). She wasn’t very happy with me when I just looked at her, confused as to why she felt so strongly about it. It was kind of funny, really. But not to her. I discovered throughout her visit and our conversation, that she and I are no longer on the same page about church. She was also really horrified that we aren’t attending a church right now, and gave my husband strict instructions to get his family back into a church. He just blew it off, but I was quite uncomfortable with her judgment and insisting that her way is the only right way. I was amazed though at how much I’ve changed in the past year or so.
Anyhow, thanks so much for your comment!
Comment by HW — January 1, 2009 @ 3:21 pm
Michelle, you know what they say about ‘great minds thinking alike,’ right?
I’m glad you are thinking about this also.
Over the Christmas break my husband has been listening to some music his cousin sent him (his cousin is not a Christian), and I’ve been teasing him about the horrors of listening to ‘secular’ music. It is nice that we are not feeling the crushing guilt of the past, but I do have so many questions for the Lord.
I sure know what you mean about the rudderless existence. When there isn’t a strict list of rules to follow, we tend to wonder whether we are still on track or not. It is kind of strange.
I’m looking forward to your post!!!
Comment by HW — January 1, 2009 @ 3:26 pm
I must continue to practice purity in the midst of this fallen world and yet live in proximity to this fallen world. These truths I live in tension through the power of God. For I do not want to become indistinguishable from fallen culture and useless in God’s Kingdom nor do I want to become pietistic, separatist and conceited.
Comment by Mark R — January 1, 2009 @ 6:06 pm
Heidi ~ This is a fantastic post!! I have become more and more real over the last couple of years and it has made me go entirely against the grain of the institution. My sense of what is right and wrong, black and white has completely changed. I still sometimes feel the pull of what I was taught but I am slowly working away from it and toward complete freedom.
Thanks for your words
Comment by Mike — January 1, 2009 @ 6:16 pm
Mark, yes… this is the tension I feel. The tightrope of what is wrong, what is right and good, and what is elitist and self-righteous.
Comment by HW — January 1, 2009 @ 6:51 pm
Mike, you are very welcome. Good to see you!
I too have changed a lot of how I view things, and becoming more and more real with other people. Even the people I know won’t like it very much.
I cringe at some of the things I used to say to “help” other people. I wouldn’t want me ‘now’ to meet me ‘then.’
Comment by HW — January 1, 2009 @ 6:56 pm
Heidi,
This is a great post! Ah, how I can most certainly relate. After I came out of the institution, a lot of my thinking swung to the extreme side of the pendulum…and I found myself with the mindset of “throwing the baby out with the bath-water.”
Now, in no way am I saying I never, ever “travel” to that side of the “extreme” path, because I still do. Like you mentioned in your post, we are always in “deconstruction” mode, although not to the “extreme” I believe we go through after leaving the institution.
The great thing I am finding is that the more and more I walk with Papa Son Holy Spirit, the more and more He’s showing me His Grace, Love AND common sense…He, Himself and Him…are changing my heart…the inside of me…thank goodness…to WANT to act, think, behave and do things that are in harmony/congruence to Him. I’m wanting less and less to carry out actions that are of the Old Nature.
It’s definitely a process though, and I most certainly have far to go in several areas of my life. But thank goodness, Papa is not too big to help me overcome….as long as I keep participating, choosing and cooperating with Him.
Again, excellent post Heidi!
Blessings,
~Amy
http://amyiswalkinginthespirit.blogspot.com
Comment by Amy — January 1, 2009 @ 7:16 pm
I know I see you around, but I am not sure I have ever been here. Hand it to Jim for sharing this post in his GReader. I will definitely subscribe.
We don’t go to church very often, but when we do we go to a place called The Bridge, and yes they do cuss “from the pulpit” (though that phrase sounds far too formal for a place like the Bridge). Not every time, but sometimes. I love it, because it seems so much like real life to me. I don’t know if that is the place your relative mentioned, because I’m pretty sure there is more than one cussing church in PDX. We’re weird that way. Anyhow, it’s “my church if I had a church”. (That’s what I call it.)
I do believe you have summed up the bottom line in this journey…that is to find one’s own boundaries and to not judge the boundaries of others. I have seen so many wonderful people go through this, and are going through this, and it gives me hope for the Church-capital-c.
Comment by Erin — January 1, 2009 @ 7:20 pm
Erin, I remember you mentioning that in a post of yours once, so it just made me wonder, although I’m sure I’ll never know for sure.
I would love to find an informal place to fellowship and ‘be me.’ I tend to see a lot more love around the people with “rough edges,” and I enjoy it.
I too have seen a lot of people going through this deconstruction process (although mostly here on-line, and not so many in person… but we live in an area that is pretty rural and traditional).
I do think we tend to major on the minor in church all too often. I know I used to. (gasp, they haven’t been to church in 3 weeks… gasp, did you see so-and-so wore jeans to church… gasp, the pastor was walking near the bar in town) rather than the major…. Jesus.
I believe God is really working on the Church as a whole. I wonder what it will look like a bit farther down this path!
Comment by HW — January 1, 2009 @ 7:35 pm
I found this post through Erin. I’m glad I did. It’s well worth the read.
Comment by Jarred — January 2, 2009 @ 9:56 am
Amy, Thank you so much for your comment! It is definitely a process of learning and growing. And it was reading your post that inspired this one, so thanks to you!
Love,
Heidi
Comment by HW — January 2, 2009 @ 10:24 am
Jarred, thank you for stopping by, and for commenting!
Comment by HW — January 2, 2009 @ 10:25 am
I am a believer in “be real”..What that means to me is that when I am in the presence of believers I am the same as in the presence of unbelievers, not judgemental or critical, but knowing that only GOD knows the heart, and each person is on a different place on the road…and for non believers to show them that I am not better than them, but I am saved by Grace and they can have that too.
This is a very good post, and very timely…lets just be real…I hate the phoney stuff.
Comment by darla — January 2, 2009 @ 5:47 pm
Darla, I keep trying to write back to you, but with a little girl on my lap it is hard to type. (She is crying about not getting her way… I can relate, haha)
I love real people, and I really like what you said. Thanks!
Comment by HW — January 3, 2009 @ 1:44 pm
This is a great post. You have hit the nail on the head. I would change the question and say “can the false be saved?”.
GOD was us to be real, failures and all. Religion has stopped that. We now have a rule book that is neither biblical or helpful. Several years back an authorwrote a book called “Can evangelicals be saved”. The book was about the sermon on the mount. When we compare the church to that standard we fall way short.
The good news is that the Lord is leading many people out of religion and into something better.
Comment by Mike — January 3, 2009 @ 10:25 pm
Mike, that is a great point… can the false be saved. I always laughed to hear Graham Cooke say that his mission was to “Reach Christians for Christ.” I’m excited to see what God does in the next few years, leading people out of religion.
Comment by HW — January 3, 2009 @ 11:04 pm
Just got off the phone with a friend in England. He too has left the church. He felt that he was serving the Institution and not the Kingdom of GOD.
I find it facinating so many people across the globe are going through this.
Comment by Mike — January 4, 2009 @ 6:34 pm
You raise some great issues here. Thanks for a thought-provoking post.
I grew up in somewhat of a “legalistic” church here in the Southeast. Fortunately, God has moved me away from that kind of thinking. I’ve learned that Christianity is not about religion…it’s about relationship. Of course, behavior and morality DO matter…but when I really love Jesus the way I should, it’s not a chore to be and do what He’s called me to be and do. Know what I mean?
Keep blogging, my friend! You’ve really got some good things to say.
Comment by David Richardson — January 4, 2009 @ 7:14 pm
Mike, I think that is what pushed us out of our comfort zone… what we were learning about the Kingdom of God. I’m sure we might end up back attending a church at some point, but with a very different focus I should hope. On the other hand, if we never go back, that is fine also. I hope to find where we fit into the Kingdom out here on the fringe. I remember the drive to fit into the institution, and the desperation to offer something of worth to it, and I honestly never want to feel that way again.
I too find it absolutely fascinating how many people are going through the same journey all over the globe. I absolutely pray that your friend finds that place that God is leading him to. Can you imagine what this is going to look like in 5 years? 10? How is the face of the church (as a whole body) going to change?
Comment by HW — January 5, 2009 @ 9:52 am
David! Hey, there. Thanks so much for your comment. Relationship. That word just sums it all up, doesn’t it?
Comment by HW — January 5, 2009 @ 9:53 am
So…how can we awaken others to the to be real?
Comment by Mike — January 5, 2009 @ 7:36 pm
Mike, wow… the big question.
I’m working on a response.
Comment by HW — January 5, 2009 @ 7:51 pm
“I too find it absolutely fascinating how many people are going through the same journey all over the globe.”
I love that, because I only really just “met” you, Heidi (though I’ve seen you around for awhile) and while your “circle” and my “circle” intersect at some points, we also both have people in our circles that the other doesn’t know. And I don’t think I’ve ever met Mike up there…(waves…nice to meet you) and I don’t even know if our circles intersect at all, but we both know people who are going through this. Now if we look at that exponentially…there are a freakin’ lot of us! That’s really what I love about the ‘net…all the people I would not know and the stories I would not have heard. It would be lonely.
Comment by Erin — January 5, 2009 @ 11:43 pm
Erin, I find so many of these connections to be amazing as well. It seems as if God is putting us in touch with one another, so even though we may be feeling rather alone on the journey, we are not without support and encouragement from others walking a similar path. And also, we have the insight that many others are going this direction. It really makes things a bit lighter.
And Erin, I’m glad we finally “met.”
Comment by HW — January 6, 2009 @ 4:05 pm
Me too!
Comment by Erin — January 6, 2009 @ 8:57 pm
Erin,
(wave back) Hi.
As disciples of Jesus we are all on this journey. Many streams of people are being pooled together. We don’t look or think the same but we are being pulled along by a force much greater than our will.
Lets get excited and bold. Let us not be afraid in being differnt.
Comment by Mike — January 7, 2009 @ 7:50 pm
Love God,
Love others with the Love of God
and i was reading today…
7:12 matthew
So in everything, do to others what you would have them do to you, for this sums up the Law and the Prophets.
in a way i think
what we want for others
is like waht we ask of God
it is what we do for and want for others
is what we are asking
seeking and knocking for.
Comment by nAncY — January 11, 2009 @ 8:42 pm
Nancy, thank you so much. Yes!
Comment by HW — January 12, 2009 @ 10:09 pm
[...] Can We Be Real (part 2) January 20, 2009 at 12:51 pm | In Wondering, journaling | This is part 2 of my thoughts about authenticity within the Christian faith. You can read part 1 here. [...]
Pingback by Can We Be Real (part 2) « To Be A Fool… — January 21, 2009 @ 2:26 pm
I love Timothy’s coffee. Breakfast blend was good but I prefer Timothy’s Kona Blend.
Comment by Ronny Bernucho — December 7, 2010 @ 3:37 pm